Baked Tilapia with Cream Sauce Recipe (2024)

Baked Tilapia with Cream Sauce Recipe (1)

ANOTHER Fish recipe – I know I know crazy right

If you did not know I am not super comfortable cooking with fish ( I think it is too much Hell’s Kitchen with Gordon Ramsey screaming that the scallops are raw)

BUT because many readers have asked for more fish recipes I am pushing beyond my comfort levels and the results are yummy 🙂

Today we ( my dad and I ) have made you a baked tilapia with a light cream sauce – simple and gluten – free

I love how simple this recipe is and that almost everything you need is in your pantry RIGHT NOW!!!

Except the fish …. I would be worried if there was fresh fish in your pantry

Here is my dad preparing the fish to be baked – he is lightly coating the fish with olive oil ( using a kitchen brush works best)

Of course my laptop is on the counter as well – I “try” and multitask finding deals and cooking — “try” is the important word here

While the fish is cooking the sauce is made. We served this fish with some steamed rice and it was a great pairing.

Side Note – The platter the fish is on is my favorite platter from my childhood – countless dinners have been served on it 🙂

I thought you would enjoy it so I used it for this dish

Also my dad choose the napkin ( not too sure where that is from )

This recipe is enough to serve a family of five – you can use fresh or frozen tilapia

Baked Tilapia with Cream Sauce Recipe

Print

: Sara

Ingredients

  • Fish
  • 4 tilapia fillets - Fresh or Frozen
  • Extra-virgin olive oil, for drizzling
  • Salt and Pepper
  • Sauce
  • ¼ cup plain Greek yogurt
  • 2 teaspoons of honey
  • 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
  • ¼ cup lemon juice
  • 1 tablespoons chopped fresh chives
  • Salt and Pepper

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 375 - line a cookie sheet with parchment paper OR use a glass baking dish spray with vegetable cooking oil
  2. Place fish on cooking tray or dish - Brush olive oil on both sides of the filet - sprinkle salt and pepper on each side - place fish into the oven
  3. Bake for about 20 - 30 minutes ( check if the fish is flaky )
  4. While the fish is baking in a small bowl whisk - yogurt, honey, mustard, lemon juice, and chives. Sprinkle a little salt and pepper ( taste to season)
  5. Transfer fish to a serving platter and pour sauce on top and serve

You'll Also Love

  • Top 25 Gluten Free Recipes

  • Pesto Tilapia Recipe

  • Olive Garden Baked Parmesan Shrimp Recipe

  • Baked Maple Salmon Recipe

Add a Comment

Comments

  • Kelly V

    This sounds so yummy! I love tilapia! Just one question… Do you need to warm the sauce up before pouring the sauce on the fish?

    • Watson

      You do not have to – that is completely up to you – we did not

  • Tracy Melhinch

    This looks wonderful!! I am going to try this next weekend! Thank you for all your hard work 🙂

  • valene gibbs

    this one sounds wonderful, I love fish

  • valene gibbs

    this looks good, I’m always looking for fish recipies to try

  • Elizabeth Bowen

    Never had Tilapia! But it sounds good

  • Katrina Brown

    MMM

  • Emmy

    I was on HCG diet for a while. This is one that I could actually use while being on it 🙂

  • Katelyn D.

    I love fish!

  • Sierra Matthews

    Yummy and probably pretty healthy

  • Ashley S.

    making this

  • Hly V

    Pinned! Sometimes tilapia can get pretty boring. I’m excited to try this

  • Heather Thiel

    Love this! There’s not enough fish recipes out there.

    (commenting for quick giveaway contest 🙂

  • Allie Rod

    this looks good! i love fish dinners!

  • verenise

    I love tilapia

  • Peggy Ramsden

    Fish recipes are always a good find.

  • Emily Adams

    I really need to try this recipe, I have pinned this previously!

  • Laurie Beck

    Cooking fish makes me a bit nervous also. I don’t like really ‘fishy’ fish, but I’m learning to like the cleaner, fresh tasting fish, like Tilapia. This sounds pretty easy and tasty.

  • Jennifer Patalsky

    I love this recipe! Tilapia is such a good fish to cook with, it doesn’t smell totally fishy and usually absorbs the flavor of whatever you cook it with. My family actually eats it, too.

  • valene gibbs

    tilapia is a favoire, i’ll have to pin this one

  • Samantha

    Can’t wait to try this, tilapia is my fav 🙂

  • Angela Heeringa

    Tilapia is the best fish…thanks for another recipe…always looking for new ways to cook it

  • Kathryn S.

    Thanks for the inspiration, now I know what I’ll be doing with the tilapia in my fridge!

  • Miranda

    Sounds yummy!

  • Kayla

    I love tilapia and this sounds like a great recipe! Been trying to cook more with fish as well!

  • Katie

    Very easy and fast recipe!!

  • Dawn Bear

    Looks good yummy

  • Kim

    I may try this, I haven’t been a fan of fish…but may make an exception for this!

  • Ashley

    I love tilapia! Must make this.

  • kelly galpin

    i love fish,i gotta try this!

  • Cyndy

    Going to have to try this for a change, looks easy and healthy.

  • Cooking Chica

    […] >>Read more onhttps://www.budgetsavvydiva.com/ […]

Baked Tilapia with Cream Sauce Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What temperature does tilapia need to be cooked at? ›

You know that tilapia is done baking when the flesh turns white and begins to easily flake with a fork. If you are still uncertain, insert a thermometer into the thickest part, and if the temperature is at or above 145°, the fish is ready.

How do you make tilapia not mushy? ›

If the pan is not hot enough, the tilapia will not crisp up but instead absorb too much oil, making them soggy. You may need to add additional butter and olive oil when cooking in batches. Tilapia cooks up quickly! Avoid overcooking, or the fish will be tough.

How do you get the muddy taste out of tilapia? ›

The over taste of mud may be eliminated by covering fish with onion rings or slices of lemon. You may also drizzle fish's meat with lemon juice. Another idea is to keep your fish for five hours in a solution of 5 litres of water, 2 round spoons of baking soda and 2 teaspoons of salt.

Should I bake fish covered or uncovered? ›

Do you bake fish covered or uncovered? Breaded and coated fish usually is cooked without being covered, but fillets and whole fish are covered for tender results.

Do I rinse tilapia before cooking? ›

The flesh of tilapia is white and flavorful, and the fish is inexpensive to raise, which contributes to its popularity. As with all fresh fish, it is important to clean tilapia thoroughly prior to cooking. Rinse the tilapia off in cold water and hold it by the tail on a flat surface, like a cutting board.

What makes tilapia taste good? ›

Fresh tilapia is good, frozen, depending where it's from can be unappetizing. Try mashed fresh garlic, smoked paprika, olive oil, salt, pepper, fresh lemon, whatever herbs you like, marinade, then cook in butter and olive oil.

Is it OK to eat undercooked tilapia? ›

Tilapia is generally considered safe to eat when properly cooked, but like any seafood, consuming undercooked or raw tilapia can pose a risk of foodborne illnesses. Just like with other fish, tilapia can potentially carry parasites, bacteria, or viruses that may be harmful if not eliminated through proper cooking.

Why do you soak tilapia in milk? ›

In this scenario, the protein in the milk binds with the compounds that cause that fishy odor, in essence extracting if from the fish. What's left behind is sweet-smelling, brighter flesh with clean flavor. (Just make sure you pour that milk down the drain.

Is tilapia a dirty fish to eat? ›

Tilapia has a bad reputation because some farming practices may make the fish unhealthy or unsafe to eat. However, if you avoid tilapia farmed in China and buy tilapia from countries like Ecuador or Peru, these issues are less of a concern. Tilapia is high in protein, low in calories, and contains many vital nutrients.

Why does tilapia sometimes taste like dirt? ›

The off-flavor is typically found in farmed freshwater fish like trout and carp, but also in pangasius and tilapia, two of the most lucrative aquaculture species in the world. The main culprit for the muddy taste is geosmin, a compound produced by aquatic microorganisms found in water where fish are raised.

How many pieces of tilapia should I eat? ›

Fish and shellfish in this category, such as salmon, catfish, tilapia, lobster and scallops, are safe to eat two to three times a week, or 8 to 12 ounces per week, according to the FDA.

Is Walmart tilapia safe to eat? ›

Yes, it is safe to eat. All of the tilapia that you're buying at grocery stores is coming from farms that are regulated.

Do chefs like tilapia? ›

Tilapia. While many seafood restaurants have it on the menu, many chefs don't like the fish, says Chef K.C. Gulbro of FoxFire and Copper Fox.

Does fish have to be cooked to 165? ›

4. Fish: cook to an internal temperature of 145˚F (63˚C) for fifteen seconds. 5. Eggs for immediate service: cook to an internal temperature of 145˚F (63˚C) for fifteen seconds.

Can tilapia be medium rare? ›

The only real consideration becomes whether to fry it at high temperature or low temperature. The temperature will be dictated by the way you like your fish. If you want it cooked through, or well done, then you will need to use a lower temperature. If you want it rare or medium rare use a high temperature.

What temperature should fish be cooked at? ›

What temperature should fish be cooked to? Fish and other seafood should be cooked to an internal temperature of 145°F (63°C). At this cooked temperature, fish meat develops an opaque, white color up to the center and flaky meat characteristics.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5857

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.